The Woman in Cabin 10's Netflix Adaptation: Missing the Mark
The Woman in Cabin 10, a thrilling novel by Ruth Ware, has been adapted for the big screen, but the Netflix version falls short in capturing the essence of its source material. The story centers around Lauren "Lo" Blacklock, an investigative journalist, who embarks on a luxury cruise, the Aurora, for its maiden voyage. However, the adaptation fails to convey the inner turmoil and complexities of Lo, played by Keira Knightley, leaving viewers with a shallow impression of the protagonist.
The novel's narrative is told through Lo's eyes, providing an intimate perspective on her thoughts and fears. Yet, in the movie, Lo's voice is notably absent, which could have been a crucial element in conveying her inner state. The director, Simon Stone, and his co-writers, Joe Shrapnel and Anna Waterhouse, might have overlooked the potential impact of a voiceover, which could have added depth to Lo's character and the overall mystery.
One of the key issues is Lo's lack of reliability as a narrator. The book hints at her struggles with alcohol and an undisclosed medication, adding layers to her character. These details could have been utilized to create a more nuanced portrayal of Lo, making her a less certain witness and a more intriguing protagonist. Instead, the adaptation focuses on the physical aspects of the mystery, leaving the audience with a superficial understanding of Lo's inner conflicts.
The controversy lies in the adaptation's failure to fully immerse the audience in Lo's psyche. A voiceover could have bridged the gap between the audience and Lo's thoughts, making the mystery more engaging and the characters more relatable. While the movie is enjoyable, it falls short of the original book's complexity and the potential for a truly captivating thriller.
Despite the shortcomings, the film is still accessible and entertaining, but it leaves a sense of incompleteness, especially for those familiar with the novel. The question remains: could a voiceover have made a significant difference in the adaptation's impact?
